XL Girls

XLGirls-LogoPornBattle
HD Videos 1.100+
HD Galleries 2.500+
Download Unlimited
Models 600+

Our rating: 82.7
Visit site
User votes: 90

Sinful BBW

SinfulBBW-LogoPornBattle
670+ HD Videos
570+ HD Galleries
Unlimited Download
200+ Models

Our rating: 71.7
Visit site
User votes: 109

Intro

Big Beautiful Girls lovers - get ready, because you are about to find out what are the similarities and what are the differences between two big-girls-with-big-tits sites – XL Girls and Sinful BBW.

XL Girls

Sinful BBW

Navigation/Usability

XL Girls

The quality of a porn site’s navigation/usability depends on various features. Some of them are more important than others. Of those that are more important, XL Girls doesn’t offer only an advanced category filtering engine. Everything else is pretty good. All important browsing and sorting options are here (by videos, models, photos, by time, rating…). Besides that, there is a filter that lets you choose XXX, lesbian or solo scenes. You can search for specific porn categories with a help of a search tab, but there are no offered choices. This site’s nice navigation/usability is completed with satisfactory offer by specific video and girl pages (description of scene and girl, stats, info, cast, rating, girl’s measurements…). Girls can be filtered by the first letters of their names. Saving favorites is helpful, and leaving comments and reading other people’s comments can be fun. Now, pagination is absolutely amazing. All existing pages are offered in a single drop-down menu, so you can access any of them in no time.

Sinful BBW

The situation here is not that different from the one on XL Girls. Members can browse the content by models, videos and pictures (videos and photos are located in Scenes section), go to bonus sites and videos, or go to Updates section (latest updates from other sites from All Porn Sites Network – see the Bonus round of this review). Sorting options are there (by title, time, rating…) but there are no filters, although there is a search tab that allows searching of one feature at a time. Pagination is average. It’s not even close to the one on XL Girls. When you go to a specific girl you’ll get nothing but her updates, and videos provide description, some statistics and cast (hyper-linked), but you can rate them, save favorites and write comments.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: XL Girls

Videos

XL Girls

You can watch 1,146+ videos (lasting from 15 to 20 minutes, averagely). Oldest scenes cannot be downloaded as full videos, and you cannot stream them at all. They can only be downloaded (as MPEG 480×368 and WMV 320×240) as five-minute clips. Newest can be downloaded, both as full scenes or divided to clips, as MP4 (640×360, 854×480 and HD 1280×720). Also, you can stream them (full scenes) in 4 quality settings – Full HD 1080p, HD 720p, 480p and 360p.

Sinful BBW

Videos on this site averagely last around 20 minutes and there are 674+ of them. You can download (there is info about the file sizes) newest scenes as WMV in 4 quality options (varying from 384×216 to HD 1280×720; full scenes or small clips), as MP4 (full scenes; one quality option – 768×432) and as mobile MP4 (full scenes; 320×180). Oldest scenes can be downloaded only as full movies and there are 2 options – MP4 (640×480) and mobile MP4 (320×240). Streaming of newest scenes offers 2 quality options – SD and HD, and there is only SD quality for oldest.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: XL Girls

Photos

XL Girls

Newest photos are offered in 3 sizes – 2000×3000, 1200×800 and 600×400 pixels, and oldest are offered in two sizes – 1200×800 and 600×400 pixels. Photos are gathered in sets (which you can download as Zip files) and there are 2,536+ sets. If you don’t want to download the whole sets, you can view photos individually and you can even use a default slideshow. Sets averagely contain between 60 and 70 photos.

Sinful BBW

The size of the images on this site varies from 720×540 (oldest) to 1024×685 (newest). No matter if you view the images on site (you can use and customize a slideshow) or download the entire sets as Zip files, the quality of images remains the same. Averagely there are 75 images or so per set, and there are 576+ sets.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: XL Girls

Models

XL Girls

Naturally, there are no slim girls here. Only big babes (from busty to extremely fat) are waiting here and there are 608+ of them. You can enjoy amateurs and pros of various ethnicity with (mostly) beautiful natural tits. Their size varies from big to enormous.

Sinful BBW

There are 206+ amateur and pro models on Sinful BBW and, as the site’s title suggests, they are all BBW (varying from really fat to simply busty). Their ethnicity, age and tits size varies, but most of them have large natural breasts. However, you can find some girls with small or average and fake tits.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: XL Girls

Updating

XL Girls

Averagely, 6 photo galleries and 6 videos are updated every week.

Sinful BBW

This one uploads only 2 videos and 2 photo sets per month.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: XL Girls

Categories

XL Girls

It’s understood that the main niche on this site is BBW but, besides that, you will find most of the usual mainstream porn categories – solo, lesbian and hardcore scenes, anal, blowjob, creampie (anal and vaginal), facial, tit-fucking (off course), stockings, threesome and others. Spanking is always hot (especially when it comes to big girls) so it’s nice that it’s offered by this site, and there is addition of some domination and bondage.

Sinful BBW

The story here is very similar to the one about XL Girls. This site offers the same categories plus gangbang, but it doesn’t offer spanking and creampie.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: It’s a tie

Bonus

XL Girls

Only one bonus site comes with the membership of XL Girls (Feed Her Fuck Her) and it offers 15 updates.

Sinful BBW

This site’s membership provides a free access to All Porn Sites Pass network which means that you’ll get more than hundred bonus sites and they offer thousands of videos, plus plenty of separated bonus videos. Some of the bonus sites are Pregnant And Fucked, Big Dicks Tiny Chicks, Bisexuals Hardcore, Granny Ultra, Anal Hell, Amateur Couples Sex, Gay Sex Sins, Big Tits Ex GF, Transsexuals Porno, Sexy Petite, Teens Love To Fuck, Foot Fetish Porn and, as you can see, there are a plenty of additional niches and models on these sites.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: Sinful BBW

Note: The amount of bonus content that is stated in this review refers to the day the review has been written. Porn sites and networks sometimes change the amount of bonus content, so potential members should check this right before joining the specific site/network, for just in case.

Prices

XL Girls

  • 3 day limited trial for $2.99 (renews at $29.99/month)
  • 1 month for $29.99 (recurring)
  • 1 month for $39.99 (non-recurring)
  • 3 months for $59.99 (recurring)

pre-checked cross-sales: No (one cross-sale is there, but you have to check it, if you want it)

Sinful BBW

  • 2 day limited trial for $1.00 (renews at $39.95/month)
  • 1 month for $29.95 (recurring)
  • 6 months for $59.95 (recurring)
  • 1 year for $89.95 (recurring)

pre-checked cross-sales: Yes

Winner Versus logo
Winner: Sinful BBW

Miscellaneous

XL Girls

No DRM. No download limits. Some exclusive special presentations. Online magazine and DVD store. Mobile and tablet access. Live chat.

Sinful BBW

It appears that there are daily download limits (“Terms” don’t say anything about it, but some users have reported it). There is no DRM. Get Laid (adult personals). Interactive porn which requires credits purchase.

Winner Versus logo
Winner: XL Girls

XL Girls

Our rating: 82.7
Visit site
User votes: 90

Sinful BBW

Our rating: 71.7
Visit site
User votes: 109

At the end of this battle we have the final score of 6:2. Normally, this should imply that XL Girls is 3 times better than Sinful BBW. Single site vs single site, that is the truth, but if we consider the total amount of content, girls and niches that memberships of these two sites provide, there is simply no way that the amount of content offered by XL Girls membership can compete with enormous amount of sites, content, niches and models provided by the membership of Sinful BBW.

Leave your reply

Other versus pages you might like

Kink On Demand Versus Insex On Demand

Today we will try to compare two extreme BDSM fetish PPV (pay-per-view) networks that offer torture, humiliation and hardcore sex. One of them is Kink On Demand and the other is Insex On Demand.

Bangbros Versus Naughty America

We can say that Bangbros and Naughty America belong in a group of world's most famous paid porn networks. I can't wait to find out which one of these two great champions will win this battle.

PAWG Versus 40 Inch Plus

This battle will oppose PAWG and 40 Inch Plus. Both sites will offer hardcore porn featuring girls that are proud owners of beautiful, large asses. Let's see who will be the winner of this battle.

Jav HD Versus All Japanese Pass

Jav HD and All Japanese Pass are Asian porn networks that our readers are already familiar with. Now it is time to compare them to each other, and see which one offers more to their members.